The cartoon by Cathy Wilcox has sparked considerable division, and we sincerely regret any pain it may have caused.
On January 11, 2026, in the aftermath of the tragic events at Bondi, our publication made a decisive editorial move to advocate for a royal commission into the brutal attack on the Jewish community. During a time when the nation was in mourning, we commenced the year with an editorial urging Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to establish a Commonwealth royal commission that would examine every facet leading up to the Bondi incident, placing the urgent issue of antisemitism at its core.
Our rationale for this recommendation stems from our belief that only a comprehensive inquiry has the potential to address the alarming rise of antisemitism in Australia, a trend that has intensified following the horrific Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, and the subsequent military actions in Gaza.
In recent weeks, our publication has showcased thousands of Australians who have called upon the Prime Minister to initiate a federal royal commission. This group includes notable figures from the business world as well as famous personalities from the sports arena, all coming together to voice their support for this crucial investigation.
Additionally, the Bondi Response group, comprising around 2000 individuals, both Jewish and non-Jewish, engaged in fundraising efforts for a media campaign advocating for justice and awareness. Their actions were driven by a moral compass, and we stood by them for the same reasons.
While The Age recognizes the necessity for such a royal commission, not all of our readers—or indeed, all Australians—share this perspective. Those differing opinions have also found expression in our publication as the country grapples with how best to respond to this heart-wrenching event.
Much discourse has emerged concerning the cartoon created by Cathy Wilcox, released on January 7. For years, The Age's cartoonists have played a pivotal role in reflecting societal hypocrisies. They critique those in power across various sectors, including politics and business, and sometimes even their own employers. This independence is vital and should never be compromised. Cartoons belong on opinion pages because they represent the artist's viewpoint—a snapshot of significant news occasions.
Wilcox aimed to critically analyze the immediate politicization that followed the shocking Bondi attack. It was not her intention to inflict harm on the Jewish community. For instance, her portrayal of Benjamin Netanyahu was based on his swift condemnation of Prime Minister Albanese’s remarks, which he claimed exacerbated antisemitism.
Some of our readers found the cartoon to be thought-provoking; however, many others, particularly within the Jewish community, felt deeply offended and hurt. We have listened to their concerns and extend our heartfelt apologies for the distress caused.
As royal commissioner Virginia Bell commences her inquiry, we anticipate more challenging discussions regarding the boundaries of free speech. The recent withdrawal of several esteemed writers from Adelaide Writers’ Week—following the festival's decision to remove controversial Palestinian author Randa Abdel-Fattah from the lineup—has already stirred debate about this topic. These withdrawals were not necessarily endorsements of her views but rather acts of solidarity for the principle of free expression.
While this publication advocates for free speech, we also recognize the potential harm it can bring. Hate speech has no place in our society, yet there must be space for individuals to share their opinions on political matters and global events. Cartoonists like Wilcox must retain their right to depict the world through their artistic lens.
It is important to note that there are numerous commentators and members of the Jewish community who do not align with the policies enacted by Benjamin Netanyahu’s government. Their voices must also be permitted to resonate without fear of censorship.
Stay informed and engaged with diverse perspectives that may challenge or reinforce your own beliefs by subscribing to our Opinion newsletter.
